By June 22, the total number of confirmed cases reported to the Monroe County Health Department had reached 17. The Salmonella cases were linked to multiple events at the Brook-Lea Country Club.

In response to the outbreak, the Monroe County Health Department inspected the Brook-Lea kitchen and reviewed its food-handling procedures. In addition, the kitchen was closed and disinfected by a commercial company. While the kitchen remained closed, the Health Department stated that it would review the possibility of allowing the club to have limited outside catering.

By June 24, the number of cases of salmonellosis linked to the Brook-Lea Country Club had risen from 17 to 53. Results of tests done on kitchen-staff stool samples showed that eight of the about 50 kitchen staff had Salmonella infections.

Over the next three weeks the number of Salmonella cases linked to Brook-Lea soared from 57 to well over 100. It was also determined that the Salmonella associated with the outbreak was Salmonella enteritidis, a virulent strain often associated with contaminated eggs.

In early July, Brook-Lea management admitted that none of its employees had attended a six-hour voluntary course on safe food handling. The Health Department first offered the food safety course in 1997 and it was available to all foodservice operators and their employees. It was only after the Salmonella outbreak that about 30 Brook-Lea employees received training in safe food-handling practices.

Proving that lightning can strike in the same place twice, on July 30, there was a second, smaller outbreak of Salmonella illnesses at Brook-Lea, yielding six more cases. Four of the cases were Brook-Lea employees. Overall, there were now 106 confirmed cases of Salmonella food poisoning in people residing in Monroe County and the surrounding area. All of these cases were linked to the Brook-Lea Country Club.