Seattle law firm files sixth lawsuit against ConAgra over Salmonella-tainted pot pies

SEATTLE, WA (November 28, 2007) – Marler Clark filed a sixth lawsuit against ConAgra today on behalf of a victim of the Banquet pot pie Salmonella outbreak that sickened hundreds. The lawsuit was filed in Yakima County Superior Court on behalf of Yakima resident Renee Barnes, who became ill with a Salmonella infection in May, 2007 after consuming a Banquet pot pie manufactured by ConAgra.

According to the lawsuit, Ms. Barnes became ill with symptoms of Salmonella poisoning within days of eating a Banquet pot pie in mid-May. She sought medical treatment for her illness on May 16 and May 23, and later learned that a specimen she had provided tested positive for Salmonella. Months afterward, Ms. Barnes learned she was one of 272 people who tested positive for the outbreak strain of Salmonella – Salmonella serotype I4,5,12:i:- and that the Banquet pot pie she had eaten was the source of her illness.

“I represent thousands of people who became ill with Salmonella after eating either pot pies or peanut butter – both products manufactured by ConAgra – this year,” said William Marler, managing partner of Marler Clark. “At this point, not one of them has been compensated for their injuries. It’s about time.”

ConAgra resumed production of its Banquet and store-brand pot pies on November 1, after introducing more stringent testing procedures for ingredients being included in ready-to-cook products and modifying cooking instructions. The firm plans to ship the pot pies to retail outlets in December and anticipates the products being on store shelves by January. 

“If ConAgra is ready to make a profit off these products again, the least they should do is right some wrongs first,” Marler continued. Marler Clark will send a representative and an environmental health expert to attend an inspection of the pot pie plant in Marshall, Missouri, on December 5th

BACKGROUND: Marler’s Seattle-based law firm, Marler Clark (www.marlerclark.com) has represented thousands of victims of E. coli, Salmonella, Hepatitis A, Listeria, Shigella, Campylobacter and Norovirus illnesses. In 1998, Marler and his current law partners formed OutBreak (www.outbreakinc.com), a non-profit food safety organization. Marler dedicates a significant amount of his time to travel to food-industry and public health conferences, giving speeches about how to prevent food poisoning and the consequences of foodborne illness outbreaks. Marler comments on foodborne illness outbreaks and litigation at www.marlerblog.com.

Salmonella outbreaks traced to tomatoes

Vindy.com today reported on the resolution of one of the last Sheetz Salmonella cases that stemmed from the 2004 Salmonella outbreak traced to contaminated tomatoes.  According to the newspaper report:
Anslinger's case was notable because it was the vehicle for the complicated discovery process — the pretrial exchange of evidence — used to determine where the tomatoes originated, said Anslinger's attorney, William Marler.

salmonella tomatoesThe settlement terms are confidential, according to Sheetz attorney Gary Zimmerman and Marler, who represented more than 130 of the sickened customers.

In August, Blair County Judge Jolene Kopriva concluded that Altoona-based Sheetz and its vegetable wholesaler, Coronet Foods, could not pinpoint where the tainted tomatoes originated. So, Kopriva dismissed claims brought by Anslinger and other customers against two tomato suppliers and six farms or other businesses that may have grown the tomatoes.
The Sheetz Salmonella outbreak was not the only one traced back to contaminated tomatoes, as evidenced by the recent outbreak at Quizno's that was caused by consumption of tomatoes.   In addition:
  • In 1990, a reported 174 Salmonella javiana illnesses, as part of a four state outbreak, were linked to raw tomatoes.
  • In 1993, 84 reported cases of Salmonella Montevideo were part of a three state outbreak that was linked to raw tomatoes.
  • In January 1999, Salmonella Baildon was recovered from 86 infected persons in eight states.
  • In July 2002, an outbreak of Salmonella javiana occurred associated with attendance at the 2002 U.S. Transplant Games held in Orlando, Florida during late June of that year. Ultimately, the outbreak investigation identified 141 ill persons in 32 states who attended the games.
  • During August and September 2002, a Salmonella Newport outbreak affected the East Coast. Ultimately, over 404 confirmed cases were identified, in over 22 states. Epidemiological analysis indicated that tomatoes were the most likely vehicle, and were traced back to the same tomato packing facility in the mid-Atlantic region. 
  • In early July 2004, as many as 564 confirmed cases of salmonellosis associated with consumption of contaminated tomatoes purchased at Sheetz Convenience Store were reported in five states, Pennsylvania, Maryland, Ohio, West Virginia, and Virginia. Seventy percent were associated with tomatoes in food prepared at Sheetz convenience stores. 
  • In 2006 two outbreaks of Salmonella-tainted tomatoes where reported by the FDA. According to Ms. Murphy, the Food & Drug Administration is now investigating two tomato-related outbreaks, with the latest blamed for nearly 100 illnesses in 19 states. FDA was already tracing tomatoes involved in another outbreak involving 183 people in 21 states. Federal authorities said that fresh tomatoes contaminated with Salmonella typhimurium served in restaurants were the likely cause of that outbreak.

ConAgra Banquet and Great Value Pot Pie Outbreak Update

Investigation of Outbreak of Human Infections Caused by Salmonella I 4,[5],12:i:-

CDC is collaborating with public health officials in multiple states across the United States and with the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food Safety and Inspection Service to investigate an ongoing multi-state outbreak of Salmonella I 4,[5],12:i:- (pronounced “four five twelve eye minus”) infections in humans. An investigation that used interviews comparing foods eaten by ill and well persons is showing that eating Banquet brand pot pies produced by the ConAgra Foods company is the likely source of the illness.

Between January 1, 2007 and October 29, 2007, at least 272 isolates of Salmonella I 4,[5],12:i:- with an indistinguishable genetic fingerprint have been collected from ill persons in 35 states. Ill persons whose Salmonella strain has this genetic fingerprint have been reported from Arizona (1 person), Arkansas (4), California (18), Colorado (9), Connecticut (7), Delaware (5), Florida (2), Georgia (2), Idaho (11), Illinois (7), Indiana (3), Iowa (1), Kansas (4), Kentucky (9), Massachusetts (7), Maryland (7), Maine (2), Michigan (3), Minnesota (7), Missouri (18), Montana (6), Nevada (6), New York (10), North Carolina (2), Ohio (11), Oklahoma (1), Oregon (4), Pennsylvania (18), Tennessee (6), Texas (4), Utah (12), Virginia (9), Vermont (2), Washington (27), Wisconsin (24), Wyoming (3). Their ages range from <1 to 89 years with a median age of 18 years; 51% of ill persons are female. At least 65 people have been hospitalized.

Salmonella outbreaks

WBTV published a press release from the Catawba County Public Health Department on its website regarding the Salmonella outbreak that has recently plagued customers of Carniceria y Taqueria Hermanos Chavez located in Newton. Following is an excerpt from the press release:
Catawba County Public Health is continuing to investigate a food borne illness outbreak. There have been 176 cases of illness reported so far. The lab has confirmed 25 cases being positive for Salmonella. “As of this afternoon, we are encouraged by the fact that there have been no further reports of people presenting with symptoms at local emergency rooms,” stated Doug Urland, Health Director at Catawba County Public Health.

Most of the people with symptoms report having eaten at Carniceria y Taqueria Hermanos Chavez located in Newton off U.S. 321 business. On Friday, November 2nd Public Health made a site visit to the restaurant and the owner was very concerned about the health of his patrons so he voluntarily closed the restaurant on that evening as a precautionary measure and it has remained closed. The owner is working closely with Public Health Officials to meet the required measures including; discarding restaurant food and sanitizing the establishment.
Not surprisingly, this week's food safety infosheet from the International Food Safety Network  focuses on Salmonella outbreaks.  The infosheet, titled, "What's up with all the Salmonella? Is it that common?" can be found below.
Salmonella Infosheet

Marler Clark files fifth lawsuit against ConAgra on behalf of man who ate contaminated Banquet pot pies

NEWS RELEASE
Contact:
Suzanne Schreck
(206) 346-1879
sschreck@marlerclark.com

SEATTLE, WA (November 13, 2007) – A Pasco, Washington man who became ill with Salmonella after eating a Banquet pot pie in September filed a lawsuit against ConAgra, the food manufacturer whose Banquet pot pies were recalled in October after they were identified as the source of a nationwide Salmonella outbreak. The lawsuit was filed in United States District Court for the Eastern District of Washington in Spokane by the Seattle law firm Marler Clark.

According to the lawsuit, the plaintiff, John Doty, ate a Banquet brand pot pie for lunch on Friday, September 28, 2007. That evening he developed a fever and by the next morning began experiencing symptoms of Salmonella poisoning, including bloody diarrhea. Mr. Doty sought medical care at a local hospital on September 30, where he was treated for dehydration and nausea. While at the emergency room, Mr. Doty submitted a stool specimen for testing that later tested positive for Salmonella serotype I4,[5],12:i:-, the strain of Salmonella the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention identified as the serotype associated with the pot pie Salmonella outbreak. Mr. Doty continues to suffer from the effects of his Salmonella illness.

“This is the fifth lawsuit we have filed against ConAgra in connection with this outbreak,” said William Marler, Mr. Doty’s attorney. “We have been contacted by dozens of people who are part of the pot pie Salmonella outbreak, and will continue to file lawsuits against ConAgra until they begin compensating our clients for damages.”

Marler Clark previously filed lawsuits on behalf of victims of the Banquet pot pie Salmonella outbreak in Washington, Michigan, Minnesota, and Nebraska.

BACKGROUND: Marler Clark has represented thousands of victims of foodborne illness outbreaks since the 1993 Jack in the Box E. coli outbreak. The firm has represented victims of outbreaks traced to lettuce, sprouts, apple juice, ground beef, peanut butter, and other foods.

Update: North Carolina Salmonella Outbreak

WSOC TV reported yesterday that the Newton, North Carolina restaurant associated with a large Salmonella outbreak may not reopen after the health department concludes its investigation into the source of the outbreak. 
Experts with the Catawba County Public Health Office said they may never know for sure what caused the outbreak at the Carniceria y Taqueria off U.S. 321 Business. The owner has scrubbed the place down, but he said he knows some customers will never come back.

Health officials are concerned the outbreak could continue to spread even though the restaurant has stopped serving. That’s because some of those who ate at the restaurant work at other restaurants in town, where they could spread the illness that has symptoms that include shaking, a high fever and diarrhea.
So far, 15 people have been confirmed ill with Salmonellosis, and over 100 people reported becoming ill after eating at Carniceria y Taqueria. 

2 more cases of Salmonella confirmed

Public health officials have confirmed two more cases of Salmonella associated with a food poisoning outbreak in Catawba County, North Carolina.  According to an article published in the Hickory Daily Record today:
The number of confirmed cases stood at 15 as of late Wednesday afternoon, but 126 people have complained of Salmonella-like symptoms, they said.

Most of the people with symptoms had eaten last week at Carniceria y Taqueria Hermanos Chavez, located off U.S. 321 business. No other source has been identified. Officials continue to investigate.
Salmonella is one of the most common enteric (intestinal) infections in the United States. Salmonellosis (the disease caused by Salmonella) is the second most common foodborne illness after Campylobacter infection. It is estimated that 1.4 million cases of salmonellosis occur each year in the U.S.; 95% of those cases are foodborne-related. Approximately 220 of each 1000 cases result in hospitalization and eight of every 1000 cases result in death. About 500 to 1,000 or 31% of all food-related deaths are caused by Salmonella infections each year. Salmonellosis is more common in the warmer months of the year.

Salmonella infection occurs when the bacteria are ingested, typically from food derived from infected food-animals, but it can also occur by ingesting the feces of an infected animal or person. Food sources include raw or undercooked eggs/egg products, raw milk or raw milk products, contaminated water, meat and meat products, and poultry. Raw fruits and vegetables contaminated during slicing have been implicated in several foodborne outbreaks.

Quizno's Salmonella outbreak likely from tomatoes

This week's food safety infosheet from the International Food Safety Network highlights a recent Salmonella outbreak that was traced to a Quizno's restaurant in Rochester, Minnesota.  From the infosheet:
Salmonella outbreak at Quizno'sDoug Schultz, spokesman for the Minnesota Department of Health was quoted as saying "We're still investigating the outbreak, and part of that investigation involves produce items being the likely vehicle for the contamination."

Tomatoes are suspected, but no definitive cause has been confirmed. The restaurant reopened after certification from Olmsted County Public Health.
Other Salmonella outbreaks have been traced to contaminated tomatoes.  In 2004, Sheetz convenience stores were the source of a Salmonella outbreak that resulted in hundreds of illnesses

Salmonella outbreak in Catawba County, NC

The Charlotte Observer reported yesterday on the closure of Carniceria & Taqueria Hermanos Chavez in Newton.  The restaurant was closed on Friday after dozens of people became ill with Salmonella infections after eating at the restaurant, according to Catawba County health officials. 

As reported by the Observer:
Since Oct. 31, nearly 100 people have reported having salmonella symptoms -- including diarrhea, vomiting, cramping, headache and fever -- and 13 cases had been confirmed by Tuesday, said Maria Reese, a spokeswoman for Catawba County Public Health.

Most of the people with symptoms had eaten at Carniceria y Taqueria Hermanos Chavez off of U.S. 321 Business in Newton, Reese said. The owner voluntarily closed the restaurant Friday after a visit from public health officials, Reese said.
Goblueridge.com reported that at least ten people's tests have come back positive for Salmonella. 

An infectious dose of Salmonella is small, probably from 15 to 20 cells.  Typically, non-typhoidal Salmonella produces a self-limiting febrile gastrointestinal illness that is indistinguishable from that caused by other bacterial enteric pathogens. Dehydration is the principal clinical concern. The incubation period – the time between ingestion of Salmonella bacteria and the onset of illness – varies from six to 72 hours.

Salmonella can cause three different kinds of illness: gastroenteritis, typhoid fever, and bacteremia.

Salmonella-Tainted Tomatoes Tied to Quiznos

Investigation continues into salmonella contamination

Health officials still seek the cause of a foodborne illness outbreak that briefly closed a Rochester restaurant in mid-October.  Quizno's Subs at 3499 22nd Ave. N.W. closed for one day because salmonella made 10 workers and customers sick.  "At last count we had 22 cases, only one person hospitalized and released," said Doug Schultz, spokesman for the Minnesota Department of Health. "We're still investigating the outbreak, and part of that investigation involves produce items being the likely vehicle for the contamination."  Tomatoes are suspected, but no definitive cause has been confirmed. The restaurant re-opened after certification from Olmsted County Public Health.  Because workers got sick at the same time as customers, health workers suspect food deliveries might have been contaminated before reaching Quizno's Subs, health officials said.